Generalizations and objectives in life
Almy Tau | October 5, 2008 | 11:33 pmI remember talking to an Indonesian in Europe, somebody who my wife knew. After exchanging pleasantries, the conversation then veered off to where I worked, where I lived and how did I get there. And then we parted ways.. a few weeks later I heard that a friend of this person needed help from a US resident so I happily obliged. Interestingly, by ways that I won’t discuss here, I found out by chance that the person lamented the fact that I chose to settle in the US.. I don’t know why. I got the impression that because I chose to live in the US, he thinks I abandoned Indonesia to the sharks and doesn’t care anymore about the country I grew up in. I found that point of view fascinating, because I’ve met or communicated with many Indonesians who think exactly the same way about me and other Indonesians who settle in the overseas– except of course, those Indonesians who themselves live overseas. It’s an ‘us vs them’ mentality. I’ve observed many discussions about whether the Indonesians living in the US forgot about their identity, they don’t love their country, they’re just in it for the money, blah blah blah.
Which brings me to the topic of generalizations. Let me first remark that those who have the opinions I mentioned above were mostly university students or professionals with at least a Bachelors degree. These critics, if you will, lump me and the other expats as one group of people — Indonesians, who consciously chose to go overseas and forget about their home and their ideals.. whatever those may be. That is a weird way of viewing people, they pretty much ignored the whole dynamics of being a human being, their personal and cultural problems and just said.. you guys are Indonesians, if you’re not working for your country then you’re wrong! And I usually always reply like this, “would you guys care about us expats if we stayed in Indonesia, jobless and drenched in all the problems happening there?”, and of course, the answer is no. If I chose at this moment to go back to Indonesia with all my idealism and try to make a difference, and fail, not one of those critics will care.. they won’t even remember who I am, save for whatever remains of this blog.
Where was I? Oh yeah, I’m still talking about generalizations. I’m not saying that those guys who consciously abandon their contractual and moral responsibilities to Indonesia don’t exist, but it’s really easy for the critics to lump us together. Let me try to present the other possibilities of why Indonesians end up overseas:
-Their parents work at Indonesian based US companies; the parents then send them overseas to study — why would they refuse?
-They become a sailor (for economic reasons), and end up settling in a different country.
-They are nurses or manual labor who get sent overseas (it’s their job), and some eventually settle down.
-They marry somebody from overseas (for the right reasons, of course).
-They become a professor/researcher somewhere.
-They get sent overseas by their company, and the company no longer exists (went bankrupt or what have you).
-They’re not comfortable living in Indonesia, with the talents and qualifications that they have. Example: what would an aerospace engineer do in Indonesia if he wants to work in aerospace? Google IPTN.
What I’m trying to bring up is that, they probably saw the problems Indonesia had but their sphere of influence was really small — meaning they had no way of correcting them. So people usually steer away from that lofty objective and move to the more urgent ones.. trying to live, make some money, do something. And of course, people have different talents and circumstances, and some seized the opportunity/job offer/scholarship based on their best judgment– this could mean going overseas, or this could mean staying back. There are probably idealists who calmly refused to go overseas, wanting to do more in their own country. Does this mean they’re the better ones though? Of course not. Like I said, people’s circumstances are different. The idealist might not have an urgent financial problem like the expat sailor did — he could afford to do so. And this brings me to ‘objectives in life’.
I’m not going to spell out my own objective in life.. if people want to know that bad, they can read all my blog entries and deduce it themselves.
To be continued…







Recent Comments